London Liberal Democrats

info@libdems4london.org.uk

Campaigning for London in Parliament, in Europe and in the London Assembly

Tom Brake Accuses Minister of Forcing Councils to Increase Council Tax at Double the Rate of Inflation

2.18.00pm UTC (GMT +0000) Thu 30th Nov 2006

Tom Brake MP

Tom Brake MP for Carshalton and Wallington

On Tuesday Tom Brake MP for Carshalton and Wallington and Lib Dem Local Government Spokesman responding to a statement in the House of Commons made by the Minister for Local Government, Mr Phil Woolas, accused the Minister of forcing Councils to increase Council Tax by double the rate of inflation.

In his reply to the Minister's statement Tom Brake said, "Does the Minister not accept that it is his settlement of 2.7 per cent. for many authorities (including Sutton Council), combined with public sector inflation and the financial impact on local authorities of the cuts in many Primary Care Trusts and many Acute NHS Trusts, that make inevitable an increase in council tax of double the rate of inflation, hitting the poorest-often our senior citizens-the hardest?"

Sutton's PCT and Acute NHS Trusts have to make savings of £34 million which is widely expected to have a significant knock-on effect on the Council's budget.

Mr Brake went on to say, "Is it not time he stopped punishing local authorities? Instead, he should congratulate them on moving forward with the Gershon savings at a rate that central Government cannot match. He should introduce a local tax based on ability to pay, give local councils control of business rates, allow fair votes for local elections and scrap the hundreds of targets that are imposed on local authorities by his Government."

In his response to Mr Brake's comments regarding the impact of deficits in the NHS on Council budgets, the Minister had no comment.

ENDS

Notes to the Editor

The full exchange between Mr Brake and the Minister is listed below.

HANSARD

28 Nov 2006 : Column 975

Tom Brake (Carshalton and Wallington) (LD): I commend the Minister for making the statement available much earlier than is usually the case. I congratulate the Government on moving to a three-year settlement, which will allow local authorities to plan much more effectively. However, it will not have escaped Members' attention that the Labour manifesto pledge back in 1997 to abolish universal and crude capping has still not been delivered. We do not have crude and universal capping. What we have is a benevolent Minister who reluctantly uses his reserve capping powers but achieves the same end, and our strong and prosperous communities still have to dance to his tune.

The Minister neatly side-stepped the question from the hon. Member for Brentwood and Ongar (Mr. Pickles) about whether and when Sir Michael Lyons' report would be published. I hope he will answer that question

28 Nov 2006 : Column 976

on the record. In relation to the three-year settlements and picking up a point that has just been made, can the Minister confirm that those will be sufficiently flexible so that if a local authority experiences a swift change, such as inward migration, or if the census data prove to be inaccurate, it will be possible during that three-year period to adjust the settlement?

On the 2007-08 announcement, does the Minister not accept that it is his settlement of 2.7 per cent. for many authorities, combined with public sector inflation and the financial impact on local authorities of the cuts in many primary care trusts and many acute trusts, that make inevitable an increase in council tax of double the rate of inflation, hitting the poorest-often our senior citizens-the hardest? Is it not time he stopped punishing local authorities? Instead, he should congratulate them on moving forward with the Gershon savings at a rate that central Government cannot match. He should introduce a local tax based on ability to pay, give local councils control of business rates, allow fair votes for local elections and scrap the hundreds of targets that are imposed on local authorities by his Government.

Mr. Woolas: The 2.7 per cent. floor that the hon. Gentleman mentions benefits his own authority, which is a floor authority. Without the floor, there would be a significant shortfall, and the hon. Gentleman and his colleagues would no doubt lobby me for the floor. I therefore expect a letter of thanks for it, although I doubt whether that will be in the Christmas box for the Woolas office this Christmas.

The Lyons report will be complete by the end of the year. [Hon. Members: "Will it be published?"] Of course it will be published. [Hon. Members: "When?"] The hon. Members for Brentwood and Ongar (Mr. Pickles) and for Carshalton and Wallington (Tom Brake) will have to be patient. That approach was used in the past with the Layfield review and other independent reports.

The answer to the question about three-year settlements is yes, because the settlement takes into account the updated data.

On council tax increases of twice the level of inflation, I repeat that the 5 per cent. figure to which I referred last year and this year is the national average, so it does not mean that council tax will rise by 5 per cent. in every authority. Council tax is set by individual local authorities, which has been the case since its introduction.

On hitting the poorest hardest, the poorest benefit most from the council tax benefit system, which contributes just under 15 per cent. of total council tax revenues. That point is often missed out from the debate for what I assume are entirely honourable reasons.

On the Gershon review, this morning I congratulated local authorities at the conference of the Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy on their success in reaching their Gershon targets a year early, and I am happy to repeat those congratulations.

Bookmark this story at: del.icio.usdel.icio.us DiggDigg FacebookFacebook LibDigLibDig redditreddit StumbleUponStumbleUpon
Print this news story
Previous news story: Tom Brake Supports NEA Warm Homes Campaign 2006 (Wed 29th Nov 2006).
Next news story: Local MP wishes everyone a Rainbow Christmas (Thu 30th Nov 2006).

Related News Stories:

Fri 14th Nov 2008:

Sun 9th Nov 2008:

Sat 25th Oct 2008:

Fri 24th Oct 2008:

Sun 19th Oct 2008:

Sun 28th Sep 2008:

Mon 19th May 2008:

Fri 14th Dec 2007:

Wed 5th Dec 2007:

Thu 1st Nov 2007:

Fri 19th Oct 2007:

Wed 10th Oct 2007:

Tue 31st Jul 2007:

Thu 5th Jul 2007:

Tue 3rd Jul 2007:

Fri 22nd Jun 2007:

Mon 18th Jun 2007:

Sun 20th May 2007:

Thu 10th May 2007:

Wed 28th Mar 2007:

Wed 21st Mar 2007:

Mon 5th Mar 2007:

Thu 1st Mar 2007:

Thu 22nd Feb 2007:

Fri 19th Jan 2007:

Wed 10th Jan 2007:

Fri 5th Jan 2007:

Sat 23rd Dec 2006:

Tue 12th Dec 2006:

Sat 9th Dec 2006:

Fri 8th Dec 2006:

Mon 4th Dec 2006:

Fri 1st Dec 2006:

Wed 29th Nov 2006:

Wed 22nd Nov 2006:

Fri 17th Nov 2006:

Sat 4th Nov 2006:

Wed 1st Nov 2006:

Wed 25th Oct 2006:

Tue 17th Oct 2006:

Sun 8th Oct 2006:

Fri 22nd Sep 2006:

Thu 10th Aug 2006:

Mon 7th Aug 2006:

Sun 12th Mar 2006:

Fri 25th Feb 2005:

Printed and hosted by Prater Raines Ltd, 82b Sandgate High Street, Folkestone CT20 3BX.
Published and promoted by London Liberal Democrats, 4 Cowley Street, London SW1P 3NB.
The views expressed are those of the party, not of the service provider.